Rogov's Ramblings
Weary of Genius


I have nothing to declare except my genius.
- Oscar Wilde


One of the fallacies of a democratic society is the mistaken notion that under the banner of freedom, anyone can become a genius. Once the crown worn by a handful of aristocrats of the human race, the idea of genius has now become so fully democratized that it has become mundane. Like common sense, nearly everyone thinks they possess genius in abundance.

Artistic-intellectual circles are particularly notorious for their claim to overflow with geniuses. Even a cursory glance at the recent international press reveals that genius in the arts has become so mundane that it is virtually impossible to succeed without it. An English postmodern film maker is reported to have an "innate genius for irony"; an Italian opera star has "a galloping genius for sensuality"; and a Russian choreographer is hailed for his "genius of motion". A South American author, a Parisian librettist, a Russian ice-skating queen and a New Orleans chef all wear the grown of genius.

Wherever we look, such geniuses seem to surround us. In the theatre, on the screen, in the plastic arts, and in fashion design, it is taken for granted that one must be a genius to become someone. Georgio Armani goes as far as to claim that in the field of fashion design "genius is a prerequisite for success" In architecture, literature and various forms of criticism, it is no longer enough to be considered bright or brilliant. Architect Howard Johnson stated that "even talent no longer counts. Only out-and-out genius will suffice." Like love and marriage or horse and carriage, creativity and genius go together.

As if to prove that genius is within the grasp of nearly all, psychologists and educators are busy churning out methods of child-rearing that promise to make geniuses of our children. Even the middle-aged are not beyond hope, and a variety of charlatans, quacks and curmudgeons-at-large (many of whom publish best selling books) promise that if only we follow their method, genius is a maximum of two months away. So far has this notion gone that the entire spectacle of serious art today is based upon the conception of genius. In fact, to be involved in any artistic or intellectual endeavor today without having a chance of being recognized as a genius is such a heartbreaking notion that people have killed themselves for less.

All of this talk is nonsense of course, an out-and-out contradiction in terms, for we have forgotten that genius is the most uncommon and valuable thing in the world. By any classical definition, the idea of genius was literally a gift from the gods, one only rarely bestowed upon a mortal, in which an impersonal creativity seemed to flow effortlessly from the mortal fountain, as in the case of a Plato, Shakespeare or Mozart. Under this conception, willpower was less important than the notion of sublime rarity, whereby the great gift seemed to have been deposited within the human being at birth and then simply bided its time until that moment when it unfolded into humbling reality.

It is worth exploring the paradox of how the meaning of the word "genius" has degenerated. The shift probably started with therise of individualism and romanticism in the 19th century. Suddenly, society seemed to encourage the development of egos that sought out genius as the burning light of their personal salvation. Thomas Carlyle pronounced that the world could no longer be satisfied with anything less than "genius-art". Nietszche wrote of man's "insatiable need to make a new Heaven out of his own Hell". Dostoevsky, Beethoven and Gauguin, were all fully conscious of the desirability of being geniuses. Genius had become separated from an act of nature. It had been reduced to a question of willpower.

This conception of genius has perpetuated in our lifetime, albeit for different reasons. Psychologist Lawrence Kohlberg suggested that our current desire to attain genius has a direct relationship to the amount of confusion in the world. Kohlberg's chain of logic is simple: the more uncertainty that exists on a day to day level, the more frantic becomes the life of contemporary men and women. Because life means change and insecurity today, nearly all intelligent people feel, at some moment or another, that they are outcasts, exiles forced to struggle not only for physical survival but for the vindication of their being. It may be natural under such super-pressures to project our egos to desperate altitudes. Genius can be one's justification for living.

One might ask, "what remains of true genius?" In the sciences, mathematics and philosophy one can still see an occasional genius of the old school, where great mental ability and originality are separated from desire and where the objectivity of the work gives purity to those who shine at it. Sadly, however, even this kind of genius - with a tradition that includes such great figures as Darwin, Spinoza and Einstein - is no longer perceived as colossal in the eyes of society. The limelight has shifted from the "pure genius" of the sciences to the self-created genius of the arts. Here the field is wide open because the arts depend upon individualism and self-inspired originality, the furthest bid that a single person can make for glory. In this sense, the arts are the last refuge for the individual to act out his attempt at personal redemption, power and godliness.

So prized is the quality of genius that it is rare not to run into tens (perhaps hundreds) of people in nearly any professional endeavor who confidentially tell you, or let it be torn from them, that they are geniuses. Alas, as genius becomes a mass phenomenon, we have the feeling that we have checked into a hotel filled with 500 Dostoevskis. The
true meaning of genius loses its reality. Genius has become as common as toothpaste.

© Daniel Rogov

[ BACK ]

Home | What's New | Tasting Notes | Wine Articles | Wine & Food | Dishes I Adore | Without Alcohol

Mostly for Pros | Issues and Arguments | Travel & Dining | Spirits | Cigars | Ramblings |

The Discussion Forum | The Recipe Index

   Israeli Wining and Dining   

This site has been provided with FREE webspace by Strat's Place
To Return to Strat's Place - Please click on the banner below